DCSIMG
 
 

Winter Soldier (1972)

Winter Soldier (1972)
Member Rating:  
In the late 1960's, the war in Vietnam was widely criticized by activists and college students across the United States, but at the dawn of the 1970's new voices joined the outcry against the war. Vietnam Veterans Against the War (or VVAW) was a group formed by men who had served in Vietnam and had come to believe that the war -- and America's presence in it -- was wrong. In early 1971, as reports of the 1968 My Lai Massacre and the court martial of Lt. William Calley were still in the news, the VVAW organized what they called "the Winter Soldier Investigation," in which Vietnam vets and VVAW members were encouraged to come forward and take part in public hearings in which they discussed war crimes they had witnessed first hand. Held in Detroit, the hearings were an emotional outpouring in which veterans discussed horrific violence against civilians, women and children, talked about how military commanders sought to dehumanize the Viet Cong in the eyes of the soldiers, and expressed their desire to prevent other young men from suffering as they did. A handful of filmmakers were on hand to document the event, and Winter Soldier is a disturbing but often moving account of men coming to terms with the horrors of war. While the makers of Winter Soldier were uncredited on screen, they included Fred Aranow, Nancy Baker, Robert Fiore, David Gillis, Barbara Koppel, Michael Lesser and Michael Weil. The title of the film and the investigation came from the work of Thomas Paine, who in 1776 wrote, "These are the times that try men's souls. The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country; but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman." ~ Mark Deming, Rovi

 Read More


Format(s):
DVD
View All Versions to rent and buy
 
 
 
 

Synopsis of Winter Soldier

In the late 1960's, the war in Vietnam was widely criticized by activists and college students across the United States, but at the dawn of the 1970's new voices joined the outcry against the war. Vietnam Veterans Against the War (or VVAW) was a group formed by men who had served in Vietnam and had come to believe that the war -- and America's presence in it -- was wrong. In early 1971, as reports of the 1968 My Lai Massacre and the court martial of Lt. William Calley were still in the news, the VVAW organized what they called "the Winter Soldier Investigation," in which Vietnam vets and VVAW members were encouraged to come forward and take part in public hearings in which they discussed war crimes they had witnessed first hand. Held in Detroit, the hearings were an emotional outpouring in which veterans discussed horrific violence against civilians, women and children, talked about how military commanders sought to dehumanize the Viet Cong in the eyes of the soldiers, and expressed their desire to prevent other young men from suffering as they did. A handful of filmmakers were on hand to document the event, and Winter Soldier is a disturbing but often moving account of men coming to terms with the horrors of war. While the makers of Winter Soldier were uncredited on screen, they included Fred Aranow, Nancy Baker, Robert Fiore, David Gillis, Barbara Koppel, Michael Lesser and Michael Weil. The title of the film and the investigation came from the work of Thomas Paine, who in 1776 wrote, "These are the times that try men's souls. The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country; but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman." ~ Mark Deming, Rovi

Theatrical Feature Running Time:
95 mins
Categories:
Documentary
Looking for special editions of Winter Soldier?
See All Versions
Subtitles:
Check All Versions
Closed Captioning:
Check All Versions
 
 
 
 

BY MAIL

 
Buy New  $16.99
 

IN-STORE

 

ON DEMAND

Blockbuster Instant Video

Watch thousands of movies instantly on your TV, tablet, mobile phone or computer with no monthly subscription. You pay only for what you watch.
 

What's Your Take?

Add to FavoritesIn Favorites  |  Share:     Email to a friendShare on FacebookShare on Twitter
    YOUR REVIEW
    WRITE A REVIEW
     
    1000 
     
    Member Reviews
     
    Chris D.

    But this is what we put our kids through when we send them to war, there is no doubt about that. I can't vouch for the acurracy of facts or testimonials, but an excellent program. Given the time and divsion in the country, it not surprisingly does have a bias to it. Most of them talk about the Marines, which is hard core boot camp and typically see the most combat action. During WWII it was found that over 2/3 of all new soldiers would not fire on another human the first time they saw the enemy. To change this, they started firing at targets that look like outlines of people, sing marching songs about killing the enemy, and get lots of propaganda so they don't hesitiate. This has continued and become even more effective, but is backfiring. Modern US wars are following a pattern of reletively brief combat and then years of police action. Dehumanizing the enemy makes for great soldiers, but terrible police officers......

    Yes   |   No

     
    David W.

    An emotionally devastating documentary that is not just about atrocities committed in Vietnam as a direct result of American policy, but also an indictment of a system that dehumanizes young men and turns them into murderers for the benefit of state and corporate interests. The men who testified were patriots who served their country and believed what they were doing was right. Eventually, they could not deny the reality of what they were involved in. It took enormous courage to speak out. Where is the evidence of lies alleged by the negative reviewers? From Wikipedia: "Since the first day of the WSI event and for more than thirty years since, individuals and organizations have sought to discredit or at least minimize the painful revelations brought forth at that event. Critics have claimed that participants were frauds; …; that their testimonies were inaccurate or just plain fabricated. To date, no records of fraudulent participants or fraudulent testimony have been produced."

    Yes   |   No

     
    Brian P.

    This is a watchable documentary with a clear agenda. It's very dated by today's standards and will surprise no one who is even passively aware of U.S. involvement in Vietnam, a subject that generally carries with it familiar and sensationalistic hyperbole that this film unironically flaunts. Not to say that there weren't nightmarish atrocities committed in Vietnam, but this film is blatantly flawed in its lack of context, not only concerning the Vietnam action, a complex conflict by any comparison, but also in terms of warfare throughout history. The presentation presumes far too much of the viewer's prerequisite understanding of the war in whole, and, perhaps purposely, lays out a stilted view, chock full of shock. Although mostly empty of educational value, it is however interesting as a period piece, and effectively conveys the ill-ease and bleak mood of the times.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Read All 14 Reviews