DCSIMG
 
 

Milk (2008) Reviews

Milk (2008)
Play Trailer and Clips
Member Rating:  
Academy Award winner Sean Penn takes the title role in Gus Van Sant's biopic tracing the last eight years in the life of Harvey Milk, the ill-fated politician and gay activist whose life changed history, and whose courage still inspires people. When Milk was elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977, he made history for being the first openly gay man in American history to be voted into public office. But the rights of homosexuals weren't Milk's primary concern, as tellingly evidenced by the wide array of political coalitions he formed over the course of his tragically brief career. He fought for everyone from union workers to senior citizens, a true hero of human rights who possessed nothing but compassion for his fellow man. The story begins in New York City, where a 40-year-old Milk ponders what steps he can take to make his life more meaningful.

Eventually, Milk makes the decision to relocate to the West Coast, where he and his lover, Scott Smith (James Franco), found a small business in the heart of a working-class neighborhood. Empowered by his love for the Castro neighborhood and the success of his business, Castro Camera, Milk somewhat unexpectedly begins to emerge as an outspoken agent for change. With a growing support system that includes both Scott and a like-minded young activist named Cleve Jones (Emile Hirsch), the charismatic Milk decides to take a fateful leap into politics, eventually developing a reputation as a leader who isn't afraid to follow up his words with actions. In short order, he is elected supervisor for the newly zoned District 5, though this seeming triumph is in fact the catalyst for a tragedy that starts to unfold as Milk does his best to forge a political partnership with Dan White (Josh Brolin), another newly elected supervisor. Over time it becomes apparent that Milk and White's political agendas are directly at odds, a revelation that puts their personal destinies on a catastrophic collision course. ~ Jason Buchanan, Rovi

 Read More


Starring:
Sean PennEmile Hirsch, (more)
Director(s):
Gus Van Sant
Theatrical MPAA Rating:
R
Format(s):
DVD  |  Blu-ray
View All Versions to rent and buy
 
 
 
 

Average Ratings

(262 member reviews)  


Member Reviews


Deborah H.

I thought this was a wonderful movie and very well performed by the actors. I wept at the end of the movie. That being said, I don't understand why people would rent a movie just so they could slam it and preach their own "Christian" views. Trust me, there's nothing in my Bible about hate being a prerequisite for being a Christian. If homosexuality offends you, don't rent the movie.

Yes   |   No


ARCY V.

Sean Penn was outstanding in this role as Harvey Milk. I thought the movie was very interesting.

Yes   |   No


Dan J.

A very good movie and recommended. The talented Gus Van Sant- as always- goes the extra mile to make ordinary scenes interesting. But I couldn't help feeling that both Van Zant and Penn were just trying to get this movie done, maybe so they could get onto their next project(s). Anyway- an easy 4 stars out of 5.

Yes   |   No


Janice M.

Sean Penn has come a long way. Excellent movie.

Yes   |   No


Cheryl G.

this movie was a little too real for me

Yes   |   No


Sean J.

I was very impressed with the movie, the acting, the cinematography and how closely each actor resembled their counterpart (spooky.) As this was not a documentary, the one sided demonstration should not be a surprise to anyone (or should we all expect two sides from every medium, during Passion of the Christ, shall we have a representative explain the Roman side and one explain the Jewish side?) The protesting that occurred in San Francisco and still occurs yearly in attempts to gain equal civil liberties (marriage, adoptive rights, health benefits, etc) can be done in two ways - with violence or without violence. Since those who participate are not using violence, they are not harming anyone, and consider that they may not enjoy seeing heterosexuals kiss anymore than heterosexuals may enjoy watching them kiss.

Yes   |   No


Roger M.

If you enjoy men kissing...this is the one 4 u.

Yes   |   No


Judy C.

This is a pretty good movie about a brave guy. Although I grew up in the 60's I didn't know much about Harvey Milk. Sean Penn did a good job.

Yes   |   No


Kathy Z.

Very worthwhile movie, it is a part of history!

Yes   |   No


Christian P.

Being straight and Christian in SF, I had a hard time watching this movie for both the overt gay lifestye portrayal and Christian bashing. Gay movement and those individuals living this way have gone through alot more than what they should. But this movie throws some of these atrocities back at the Christian community without telling the full story or considering that there are both good and bad oucomes in every organization. I feel that media like this is trying to put the shoe on the other foot. Lesson learned: Being hated often leads to hating.

Yes   |   No


 
 
 

BY MAIL

 

IN-STORE

 

ON DEMAND

Blockbuster Instant Video

Watch thousands of movies instantly on your TV, tablet, mobile phone or computer with no monthly subscription. You pay only for what you watch.
 

What's Your Take?

Add to FavoritesIn Favorites  |  Share:     Email to a friendShare on FacebookShare on Twitter
    YOUR REVIEW
    WRITE A REVIEW
     
    1000 
     
    Member Reviews
     
    Deborah H.

    I thought this was a wonderful movie and very well performed by the actors. I wept at the end of the movie. That being said, I don't understand why people would rent a movie just so they could slam it and preach their own "Christian" views. Trust me, there's nothing in my Bible about hate being a prerequisite for being a Christian. If homosexuality offends you, don't rent the movie.

    Yes   |   No

     
    ARCY V.

    Sean Penn was outstanding in this role as Harvey Milk. I thought the movie was very interesting.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Dan J.

    A very good movie and recommended. The talented Gus Van Sant- as always- goes the extra mile to make ordinary scenes interesting. But I couldn't help feeling that both Van Zant and Penn were just trying to get this movie done, maybe so they could get onto their next project(s). Anyway- an easy 4 stars out of 5.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Read All 262 Reviews