The Great Water (2004) Reviews

The Great Water (2004)
Member Rating:  
A man near the end of his life relives a crucial period from his youth in this powerful drama. Lem Nikodinoski (Meto Jovanovski) is a prominent Macedonian politician who has suffered a severe heart attack. As Lem drifts between life and death, his mind wanders to his childhood, and he observes his younger self (played by Saso Kekenovski) during his days in a camp for children whose parents were unwilling to embrace Russia's Stalinist regime following World War II. Ariton (Mitko Apostolovski), the camp's headmaster, is a strong taskmaster, but he displays a genuine compassion for his charges; Olivera (Verica Nedeska), his second in command, takes a more stern approach, and is willing to dole out physical punishment to any child who does not absorb her Stalinist teachings. One day, a new boy enters the camp, Isak (Maja Stankovska), who displays a calm but resilient nature that's different from the fearful attitudes of the other children. After initial resistance, Lem becomes close friends with Isak, and their friendship helps Lem confront the horrors of camp life in a new way. Writer and director Ivo Trajkov cast teenage actress Maja Stankovska to play Isak after a long series of unsuccessful auditions failed to find a young man who had the right look for the role. ~ Mark Deming, Rovi

 Read More


Starring:
Saso KekenovskiMaja Stankovska, (more)
Director(s):
Ivo Trajkov
Format(s):
DVD
View All Versions to rent and buy
 
 
 
 

Average Ratings

(10 member reviews)  


Member Reviews


Nikolay S.

The cast is perfect and represents the reality in Yugoslavia's Republic of Macedonia. The story reveals the brainwashing that occurs over that simple people and the invention of their new nationality in post war years. Unfortunately the director is not liberate from the unquestionably terrible view over near history as his interview in Prague reveals. Ivo Trajkov still believes that communist party “liberated” Macedonia (from whom he does not say) and presumably made something good for those poor people. In the film the “enemy” children parents are describe as “fascist, collaborators” and not with their real “sin” Bulgarians. All in all very useful movie to help you realize the problems of modern R. of Macedonia identity crises.

Yes   |   No


Steve H.

Warning - while the movie was good, disk 2 is not a continuation of the movie. Disk 2 is the soundtrack. While the music is enjoyable, do not expect a continuation of the movie.

Yes   |   No


Joseph W.

Subtitled movies can be hard to follow many times but this movie had me jumping ahead mentally. Almost too graphic for the mind to comprehend and yet I have no doubt things were probably worse than portrayed. I can't imagine living in times like these but I would have to guess someday people will say the same about the times we live in relative to 2005 and beyond.

Yes   |   No


Kathy B.

This drama that is gripping and the acting is excellent one can get absorbed in the dialog and also casting did a wonderful job of the right actors and looks for the story.

Yes   |   No


Allan M.

It's a hard film to pigeonhole since its storyline develops along emotional memory, metaphorical and subjunctive lines. Characters are stand-ins for belief possibilities on the personal versus political (read public) level. In short, a lovely portrayal of the moral bewilderment of children who live "Do as I say, not as I do" on a daily basis in a place where everything comes at the price of pieces of yourself. Watch Lord of the Flies either before or after viewing this for a better connect with Communism under any of the Grand Masters of Destiny.

Yes   |   No


Linda M.

This was very intent and sad but more truth in it than people know. War has bad effects on children.

Yes   |   No


RAFAEL A R.

I truly enjoyed this movie. A bit difficult to follow, but once you get the hang of it, is great and it gets you. Very interesting on how things were under the "Great" Stalin.... how children were litteraly brain-washed into the garbage of stalinism and all it represented.. a good "educational movie" on totalitarianism that does not let one think for himself!!!

Yes   |   No


James V.

Visually lovely, even if its setting and subject are ugly as hell, THE GREAT WATER doesn't work as often as it does. Telling the story of childhood trauma from the point of view of an old politico as he is taken to the emergency room, the movie makes this elderly character a "memory" participant in his younger life. While this is not confusing, neither is it useful, since it helps turn a terrible tale into a sweeter one via nostalgia, otherworldliness and a rosier-than-real, sepia look. The film's most interesting feature is its investigation of the immediately post-WWII rise of Stalinism in the former Yugoslavia, especially the forcing of its citizenry to give up religion in favor of the State. To choose between an un-provable, backward faith and Communism as practiced by Stalin is to find oneself in perhaps the ultimate rock-and-hard-place position. However, the movie's slow pace and heavy symbolism only weigh things down without adding much to the proceedings.

Yes   |   No


Anne R.

seemed like a good movie but the disc was in such scratched poor condition, we were unable to see the film.I think we will try to get it again--

Yes   |   No


Sharon G.

Because the disc came to us cracked, we were unable to play it.

Yes   |   No


 
 
 

BY MAIL

Monthly Subscription
NEW! 7 - Day Rental
No subscription required. Usually ships in 24 hours.
 

IN-STORE

 

What's Your Take?

Add to FavoritesIn Favorites  |  Share:     Email to a friendShare on FacebookShare on Twitter
    YOUR REVIEW
    WRITE A REVIEW
     
    1000 
     
    Member Reviews
     
    Nikolay S.

    The cast is perfect and represents the reality in Yugoslavia's Republic of Macedonia. The story reveals the brainwashing that occurs over that simple people and the invention of their new nationality in post war years. Unfortunately the director is not liberate from the unquestionably terrible view over near history as his interview in Prague reveals. Ivo Trajkov still believes that communist party “liberated” Macedonia (from whom he does not say) and presumably made something good for those poor people. In the film the “enemy” children parents are describe as “fascist, collaborators” and not with their real “sin” Bulgarians. All in all very useful movie to help you realize the problems of modern R. of Macedonia identity crises.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Steve H.

    Warning - while the movie was good, disk 2 is not a continuation of the movie. Disk 2 is the soundtrack. While the music is enjoyable, do not expect a continuation of the movie.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Joseph W.

    Subtitled movies can be hard to follow many times but this movie had me jumping ahead mentally. Almost too graphic for the mind to comprehend and yet I have no doubt things were probably worse than portrayed. I can't imagine living in times like these but I would have to guess someday people will say the same about the times we live in relative to 2005 and beyond.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Read All 10 Reviews