DCSIMG
 
 

State and Main (2000) Reviews

State and Main (2000)
Play Trailer and Clips
Member Rating:  
Echoing the themes of Living in Oblivion and Irma Vep, David Mamet's seventh feature centers on the havoc wrought on the inhabitants of a small town by a troubled film production. After its leading man's propensity for teenage girls gets them banished from their New Hampshire location, a film crew relocates to the small town of Waterford, VT, to finish shooting "The Old Mill." As its title suggests, the film depends on the presence of a genuine mill, something the town is reported to possess. Unfortunately, with only days before principal photography begins, it becomes apparent that the mill in fact burned down decades ago. Unfazed, the film's director, Walt Price (William H. Macy), places his faith in the ability of first-time screenwriter Joseph Turner White (Philip Seymour Hoffman) to alter the script; what he doesn't count on is White's apparently bottomless reserve of angst-fueled writer's block. The film's leading lady (Sarah Jessica Parker) refuses to do her contracted nude scene unless she's give an ungodly sum of cash, while a foreign cinematographer offends the locals by messing with an historic firehouse, and the leading man, Bob Barrenger (Alec Baldwin), dallies with Carla (Julia Stiles), a crafty local teen. Everything comes to a head after Barrenger and Carla are injured in a car accident, which leads White to another emotional quandary and into the arms of Ann Black (Rebecca Pidgeon). ~ Rebecca Flint Marx, Rovi

 Read More


Starring:
Alec BaldwinCharles Durning, (more)
Director(s):
David Mamet
Theatrical MPAA Rating:
R
Format(s):
DVD
View All Versions to rent and buy
 
 
 
 

Average Ratings

(12 member reviews)  


Member Reviews


Rob L.

I'm continuously amazed how people review movies here considering everything but the film itself. People here complain there are few "memorable lines" and lots of big name actors but not much to show for it. However, this movie is more complex than others have suggested, and isn't built around a few catch phrases, but a subtly nuanced and brilliant script. Each character is fully realized with a unique dialogue and rhythm. As for the whole "big name actor" argument, people should take note that this is an ensemble performance with almost equal screen time for each character. This isn't a starring vehicle, but rather a group performance. I find the film to be a quite honest view of the effect of Hollywood on small town USA, and the quirks foibles, and sheer in the moment thought process that comes with it.

Yes   |   No


Tucker P.

The cast is wonderful and the storyline is even better. I love the part about re-sealing the Evian water after filling it with tap water because either they were over budget or just couldn't find it in the town the movie was set in. I really liked this movie and noticed that the only other reviewer at the time of my review did not! -T

Yes   |   No


Chuck L.

Finally a "movie about movies" that I genuinely liked, with continual momentum. Each actor was so natural; compassionate, belligerent, busy, arrogant. If you like the movie, you can hear the actors voices on the commentary track -- surely it entailed 10x more effort than most commentaries -- I think because it was fun for them, not work. This DVD is a riot.

Yes   |   No


William S.

A fun diversion on a day with little else to do. The story line is not deep, but the actors showed a great ability to develop the characters. Julia Stiles shows why she is picked for these teen angst roles. She will definitely continue to develop into a memorable actress.

Yes   |   No


Joseph N.

I thought this movie was pretty good. Lots of stuff going on to keep the interest up. Watch the marker board about the dinner party....when the assistant accidentally erases and then re-writes the invite on the board she is supposed to mess up and mark it on the wrong date but she clearly puts it on the correct date. Later in the movie as the dinner party nears the board magically shows the date a day late setting up the missed dinner party scenes. The editors obviously left this mistake in hoping no one would notice. :)

Yes   |   No


Nathan L.

If you enjoy movies for the dialogue, you will definitely enjoy this one. William Macy and Phillip Thomas are excellent in depicting a director/writer relationship. A little bit comedy and little bit drama in an offbeat story about Hollywood heavyweights invading a small New England town. You cannot go wrong with David Mamet.

Yes   |   No


Victoria B.

What agreat, fun movie! Something a bit different for a change. Great cast. Sit back and enjoy this one.

Yes   |   No


Anne M.

First off, Philip Seymour Hoffman was amazing. Sadly, the rest of the huge cast of excellent actors really doesn't do much for the film. It's okay. The plot had some nice twists and turns, but it was lacking. This really had the potential to be a five star film.

Yes   |   No


Jeff W.

Because of the BIG NAMES in this cast I have to say this was a disappointment. The story was fairly good and there were some funny aspects to it. I just kept waiting for it to become something other than forgettable. I wouldn't say it's a waste of time, but It's not a "must see" by any stretch.

Yes   |   No


Justin S.

This movie tries to be clever and witty and comes up very short. Don't waste a spot in your Queue on this one. So many brilliant actors and so few good lines, it really is a shame.

Yes   |   No


 
 
 

BY MAIL

 
Buy Previously Viewed   $2.39
(disc only) 

 

IN-STORE

 

ON DEMAND

Blockbuster Instant Video

Watch thousands of movies instantly on your TV, tablet, mobile phone or computer with no monthly subscription. You pay only for what you watch.
 

What's Your Take?

Add to FavoritesIn Favorites  |  Share:     Email to a friendShare on FacebookShare on Twitter
    YOUR REVIEW
    WRITE A REVIEW
     
    1000 
     
    Member Reviews
     
    Rob L.

    I'm continuously amazed how people review movies here considering everything but the film itself. People here complain there are few "memorable lines" and lots of big name actors but not much to show for it. However, this movie is more complex than others have suggested, and isn't built around a few catch phrases, but a subtly nuanced and brilliant script. Each character is fully realized with a unique dialogue and rhythm. As for the whole "big name actor" argument, people should take note that this is an ensemble performance with almost equal screen time for each character. This isn't a starring vehicle, but rather a group performance. I find the film to be a quite honest view of the effect of Hollywood on small town USA, and the quirks foibles, and sheer in the moment thought process that comes with it.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Tucker P.

    The cast is wonderful and the storyline is even better. I love the part about re-sealing the Evian water after filling it with tap water because either they were over budget or just couldn't find it in the town the movie was set in. I really liked this movie and noticed that the only other reviewer at the time of my review did not! -T

    Yes   |   No

     
    Chuck L.

    Finally a "movie about movies" that I genuinely liked, with continual momentum. Each actor was so natural; compassionate, belligerent, busy, arrogant. If you like the movie, you can hear the actors voices on the commentary track -- surely it entailed 10x more effort than most commentaries -- I think because it was fun for them, not work. This DVD is a riot.

    Yes   |   No

     
    Read All 12 Reviews